If It Works, Don’t Touch It

On June 28, 2024, Japan’s then Minister for Digital Transformation, Taro Kono, formally announced that his government had won the war on the floppy disk, meaning that the 1,034 regulations that still required every citizen and company to submit paperwork on that 1.44-megabyte plastic storage device from the 1980s, one the rest of the planet had abandoned more than twenty years earlier, had been repealed.

How did Japan go from setting the technological course of the planet to becoming the country that doesn’t dare touch what works?

The Country That Was the Future

By: Gabriel E. Levy B.

One word that perfectly defines Japan is paradox, and that is no exaggeration, since it is the country that invented the Walkman, the CD player, the handheld game console, the bullet train and the QR code, the same country that flooded the planet with flat-screen televisions, that put plasma into a screen, that mass-produced personal computers, but that today still sends faxes and makes massive use of the fixed telephone line, while China and South Korea have digitized practically the entire daily life of their citizens and already surpass it in practically every field of technological innovation.

To understand this phenomenon a little history is needed, since during the 1980s Japan was synonymous with the future, everything innovative came from Japan, it was the most technological country in the world, and it even defied tradition itself by breaking the Swiss hegemony in the watch industry and the American one in the automotive industry.

Sony, Panasonic, Toshiba, Hitachi, NEC, Nintendo and Sharp flooded homes across the planet with every kind of television, recorder, video game, watch and calculator, while their semiconductor plants came to produce in 1988 around 50% of all the chips or semiconductors manufactured around the entire world at that time, a figure that no other Asian country has reached or even matched since, not even Taiwan, which is the largest global power in this field.

Today that share hovers at barely 7% according to Japan’s Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry, METI, while its technological neighbors, China, Taiwan and South Korea, along with countries from other latitudes such as the United States, divided up the business, leaving Japan completely behind.

For historian Chris Miller, professor at Tufts University and author of the book Chip War, the Japanese completely lost the battle of the business model, since they concentrated on perfecting ever more reliable technology, while the others concentrated on innovating and making mass-production models far more efficient.

The rankings confirm the decline, since in the 2025 World Digital Competitiveness Ranking the Land of the Rising Sun holds a dismal 30th place among 69 economies, and in the 2024 edition it came in last, 67th, in business agility. This study incorporates concepts such as business agility, efficiency, productivity and of course innovation, that is, the capacity of companies to react quickly to different changes, and although WIPO’s Global Innovation Index 2025 keeps it in 12th place among 139 economies and second in the world in global patent families, the Japanese government itself acknowledges that it is far from its goal of reaching fourth place by 2035, a spot already held by South Korea, the country that forty years ago copied practically everything technological from the Japanese.

The Wisdom of the Elders

To understand the phenomenon one has to look at culture before technology, since Japan is a society that venerates accumulated experience, where like in no other country in the world the knowledge of the elderly is the greatest sociocultural asset, where nenko joretsu, that is, promotion by years of service rather than by results, still defines who is in charge in the large corporations, while ringi, decision by consensus in which a document circulates from desk to desk collecting approval seals, turns any change into a bureaucracy and a process of months or even years, all under the philosophy that engineers around the world sum up in the phrase “if it works, don’t touch it” and that the Japanese practice with religious devotion, more as a mantra than as a corporate strategy.

Parissa Haghirian, professor of international management at Sophia University in Tokyo, argues that the people who make the decisions in Japanese companies are older people who have never worked at another company, who have never measured themselves against other peers, whose only reference is what they have always done the same way and perfected with cult-like devotion, this being the reason they distrust ideas that come from outside, and that paternalistic decision-making structures, added to the belief that anyone can fill a technical post, constitute the greatest obstacle to the country’s digital transformation and of course to innovation as a higher good.

The result is what Professor Takeshi Natsuno, of Keio University and creator of the i-mode mobile Internet system, christened in 2009 the Galapagos Syndrome, in a crystal-clear allusion to Charles Darwin and his theory of the evolution of species, which he identified particularly in that Ecuadorian archipelago, since the Japanese cell phones of the time were technical marvels incapable of surviving outside their islands, something that is repeated today with the ATMs that reject foreign cards and still run on magnetic-stripe technology, the paper passbooks instead of debit cards, the hanko, that is, the personal ink seal with which the Japanese still sign all their contracts in the best style of the 1970s, the infinite and innumerable procedures that demand paper, and the office computers that run on systems more than twenty years old, with Windows operating systems that Microsoft stopped updating decades ago, which is why it is common to find at companies such as Toshiba computers of that brand built at the turn of the century running Windows 98.

A Toyota Between a BYD and a Kia

The best metaphor for Japan is a Toyota, since the company from Aichi Prefecture closed 2025 as the largest automaker on the planet for the sixth consecutive year, with more than eleven million vehicles sold, of which around 42% were hybrids and barely 2% pure electrics, a proportion that reflects to the letter the philosophy of its chairman Akio Toyoda, who insists that electric cars will never exceed 30% of the global market and that the combustion engine will continue to exist, but which also uses the same production methods as decades ago, methods that have been perfected, matured and tested, but never changed.

Meanwhile China’s BYD, which completely abandoned gasoline engines in 2022, sold 4.6 million vehicles in 2025, all electric or plug-in hybrids, overtook Ford, dethroned Tesla as the brand that sells the most pure electrics on the planet and announced in June 2026 that it intends to snatch the world crown from Toyota within five years, while the Korean Hyundai Kia group, for its part, is already the third-largest global manufacturer with 7.3 million units and one of the most award-winning electric lineups in the industry, and while Toyota keeps using the same dashboard design it drew up in the 1980s with minimal variations and little computerized technology, Chinese and Korean cars are full of screens and ooze technology to the point that many of them already incorporate autonomous driving features.

But Toyota remains the leader for now for one single reason: it is the most reliable, just as all the Japanese are, and that is why the analogy is perfect, since they are not the most innovative or the most technological, but they are the best, just as happens with a Toyota Corolla that can run 400,000 kilometers without opening the engine, something no buyer of a BYD or a Kia can guarantee yet, however, in the race to define what the cars of 2040 will look like, the Corolla is in the slow lane.

The Price of Never Failing

The truth is that this obsession with the proven has a flip side the rest of the world envies, since the Shinkansen, the bullet train that began running on October 1, 1964, has carried more than ten billion passengers without recording a single death by derailment or collision in more than sixty years, with an average delay of 24 seconds per train on the Tokaido line, and not even the earthquakes of 2004 and 2022, which knocked two trains off the rails, managed to break that streak.

That same zero-defect culture explains why the fax, which came to be present in 33.6% of Japanese households, is still switched on in the ministries, since when the government proposed eliminating it in 2021 it received close to 400 formal objections from its own agencies, which argued that it is a reliable channel when networks collapse, just as happened with public telephones during the great earthquake of 2011, when calls from phone booths multiplied tenfold, which is why the law requires NTT to still maintain some 108,000 of those devices on the streets, and that is not even the most incredible part, but rather the very fact that ordinary people still use them on the streets, since many Japanese, especially the elderly, refuse to own and use a cell phone and prefer the landlines in their homes and of course the very reliable public telephone.

Japanese innovation also survives in the place where nobody sees it, since its companies control more than half of the world market for semiconductor materials and Sony manufactures nearly half of the planet’s image sensors, without which neither an iPhone nor a BYD could see, and although many of their buyers find cheaper options in China, they acknowledge that Japanese products remain the most reliable.

The big winners of the Japanese paralysis are obvious, since Samsung and SK Hynix took the memory chips that Toshiba and NEC once dominated, TSMC took advanced manufacturing, BYD, Geely, Xiaomi, Hyundai and Kia took the electric car and the American platforms took the software, while the losers are the Japanese themselves, condemned to sustain legacy systems that, according to METI, will cost the country up to 12 trillion yen a year, close to 80 billion dollars, the phenomenon the ministry itself christened the “2025 digital cliff”.

Winners, Losers and a Latin American Lesson

The first thing we would have to acknowledge is that the phrase “if it works, don’t touch it” hardly applies to Latin America, since in our region it is rare for something to work well.

On one hand we should learn from Japanese reliability, which our countries, with their blackouts, their lines, their endless paperwork, their forms in triplicate or ID documents photocopied at 150%, and their government platforms that crash on enrollment day, are far from matching in efficiency, and on the other hand, just as we have repeatedly warned in previous articles on this portal about the digital divide, respect for the way things have always been done, so deeply rooted in our ministries, universities, banks, city halls and telecommunications operators, can become a trap just as costly as Japan’s, especially for the small operators that still manage their networks in spreadsheets.

That is why in Latin America we are possibly so far behind, since neither do things work well enough, as they do in Japan, to justify keeping them the same, nor do we take on the risk of innovation with quality the way South Korea does, so we could paraphrase the Chilean singer-songwriter Víctor Jara: “We are nothing, neither chicha nor lemonade.”

In short, Japan lost global leadership in technological innovation by turning its virtues into a cage, since veneration for the experience of the elders, promotion by seniority, decision by consensus and the philosophy of not touching what works produced the safest train, the most precise factories, the most durable cars, the cleanest streets and the most punctual public services in the world, while leaving the country without the capacity to bet on what does not yet work, which is, in the end, the only possible definition of innovating.

It remains to be seen whether the 65-billion-dollar bet in subsidies for Rapidus and for TSMC’s plant in Kumamoto manages to give Japan back a place at the frontier of two-nanometer chips in 2027, or whether it ends up being an empty gesture by a country that prefers to remain the Toyota of the world, reliable, predictable, punctual, durable and a little behind the times, while BYD and Kia speed past it.

References

  1. (2024, July 3). Japan declares victory in effort to end government use of floppy disks. Reuters, via Malay Mail. https://www.malaymail.com/news/tech-gadgets/2024/07/03/japan-finally-declares-victory-in-effort-to-end-government-use-of-floppy-disks/142613
  2. Yeung, J. (2025, August 10). Japan used to be a tech giant. Why is it stuck with fax machines and ink stamps? CNN, via RNZ. https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/world/569547/japan-used-to-be-tech-giant-why-is-it-stuck-with-fax-machines-ink-stamps
  3. (n.d.). Why Japan finds it so hard to digitally transform. https://www.itpro.com/business-strategy/digital-transformation/369577/why-japan-finds-it-so-hard-to-digitally-transform
  4. Tabuchi, H. (2009, July 19). Why Japan’s cellphones haven’t gone global. The New York Times.
  5. Miller, C. (2022). Chip War: The Fight for the World’s Most Critical Technology. Scribner.
  6. World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO). (2025). Global Innovation Index 2025: Japan ranking. https://www.wipo.int/edocs/gii-ranking/2025/jp.pdf
  7. IMD World Competitiveness Center. (2025). IMD World Digital Competitiveness Ranking 2025. IMD.
  8. The Japan Times. (2024, November 15). Japan ranked 31st in digital competitiveness, 92nd for English skills. https://www.japantimes.co.jp/business/2024/11/15/economy/japan-digital-competitiveness-english-ranking
  9. The Japan Times. (2024, September 25). Japan plans chip revival with help from TSMC. https://japantimes.co.jp/2024/09/25/special-supplements/japan-plans-chip-revival-help-tsmc
  10. (2025, December 15). Japan’s $65 billion bet: Inside the government’s semiconductor revival plan. https://apps.digitimes.com/news/a20251215PR201.html
  11. Japan’s Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry (METI). (2018). DX Report: Overcoming of the IT system 2025 cliff and full-scale development of DX. METI.
  12. com. (2024). Safety and convenience: How the Shinkansen changed Japan. https://www.nippon.com/en/in-depth/d01045/
  13. com. (2022). Japanese emergency call survey highlights free pay phone function. https://www.nippon.com/en/japan-data/h01837/
  14. Unseen Japan. (2021). Why Japan’s love for fax machines just won’t die. https://unseen-japan.com/japan-fax-still-popular/
  15. Japan External Trade Organization (JETRO). (2025). Invest Japan Report 2025, chapter 3. https://www.jetro.go.jp/en/invest/investment_environment/ijre/report2025/ch3/sec3.html
  16. (2026, January 2). BYD new global BEV sales leader, displacing Tesla. https://cleantechnica.com/2026/01/02/byd-new-global-bev-sales-leader-displacing-tesla/
  17. (2026). BYD targets overtaking Toyota as world’s biggest carmaker in 5 years. https://www.carexpert.co.nz/car-news/byd-targets-overtaking-toyota-as-worlds-biggest-carmaker-in-5-years
  18. China EV Home. (2026, February 12). BYD overtakes Ford in 2025 global sales, ranks sixth among automakers. https://chinaevhome.com/2026/02/12/byd-overtakes-ford-in-2025-global-sales-ranks-sixth-among-automakers/
  19. (2024). Toyota chairman predicts battery electric cars will only reach 30% share. https://www.nada.org/nada/nada-headlines/toyota-chairman-predicts-battery-electric-cars-will-only-reach-30-share